top of page

2431 I STREET NW

Year Built

1881

Click photo below to see full sized image.

unnamed.png

D. Vogt, 2022

Documents

2431 I St 2014 floor plan, Redfin listing

Ellick Sharp arrested for colliding with a street car, along with other charges, April 29, 1922

History

The white brick house at No. 2431 features a plaque indicating that (Irish American contractor) Peter McCartney built the house for owner John Casey in 1881.

In 1983, the house had simple molded framing around the windows and doors with an elaborate arcaded brick cornice (suggesting a Moorish appearance) with parallel bring string cornice just below. It has a first-story polygonal bay. The Bay features double hung windows on first floor with two windows above. (EHT Traceries)

Resident/Owner

1877 - Jonathan Gramm, grocer (City Directory)
1883 - John H. and Margaret Leonard. Son William J. Leonard, dies at age 15 (Evening Star, Sept. 24, 1883, p. 3)
1887 - Resident J.B. Ehrmantrout (?) applies for a liquor license (The Critic and Record, Nov. 7, 1887, p. 1).
1889 - the remaining contents of the general store including the countertop, counter scales, jellies and canned goods are auctioned off by Weeks & Co. auctioneers (Evening Star, Mar. 26, 1889. p. 6).
1891 - Michael and Mary Brennan, Michael dies at age 54 (Evening Star, Aug. 26, 1891, p. 5)
1893 - William B. Rapp, collector (City Directory, p. 775)
1895 - John Ganley and family. Della and John Jr.
1895 - John Ganley, Jr. makes the news by hitting his father in the mouth with his fist. (The Times, July 20, 1895, p. 8). In 1898, John Jr. once again attacks his dad and charged with disorderly conduct (Wash, Post, Jan. 26, 1898, p. 2.)
1897 - Daughter Della Ganley, has a coming out event, ( Evening Star, Dec. 31, 1897, p. 8). In 1898, Della marries John Hirsh at St. Stephens Roman Catholic Church on Pennsylvania Ave. The reception is held at the house (Times, Nov. 1, 1898, p. 5).
1897 - Michael Murdock dies at the house from heart failure. (Wash. Post, Jan. 17, 1897, p. 3)
1901 - Mrs. B. R. Foley and family live in the house, but are spending their summer at Lower Cedar Point villa (Evening Star, Aug. 8, 1901, p. 7)
1901 - The house rents as a six rooms "brick house in splendid condition." Neighbors at 2435 I St. have the key to show those who have interest (Evening Star, Nov. 8, 1901, p. 14).
1910 - Charles Holmes (b. 1846, VA) resided in the house at the time of the 1910 Census. He was in the Union Army.
1911 - There is a Help Wanted by a colored man seeking position as a "Fireman in apt house, or stable boss." (Evening Star, Sept. 18, 1911, p. 15).
1914 - James Britt
1917- George Shoulders (Evening Star, Aug. 5, 1917, p. 3)
1917 - William Hill (Times-Herald, June 24, 1917, p. 10)
1920 - James Hill, government employee, daughter Emily, b. 1915/DC
1921 - ? - initial only "L", laborer and Lillian Grant, age 6, b. 1915, DC
1922 - Ellick Sharp (colored) was arrested for driving under the influence, colliding with a street car, failing to stop, failing to have an operators permit and assaulting a police officer. The accident occurred on Connecticut Ave., south of Dupont Circle and no one was hurt (Evening Star April 29, 1922, p. 2)
1928 - Eugene Allen, driver of a "machine" was in accident with an automobile at New York Ave and 1st St. (Evening Star, July 30, 1928, p. 15)
1935 - Thomas Brooks (colored), age 26 suffered a crushed foot when a boiler he was installing broke from its fastenings and fell on him. 2448 Snows Court resident John Van Horn (colored), age 42, was also injured in the accident suffering a fractured skull. (Washington Herald, Aug. 8, 1935, p. 17)
1936 - Want ad placed by a "colored" woman, experienced in general housework, good cook and laundress, seeking work in which she would "go home nights," with a salary not under $10 weekly (Evening Star, Apr. 27, 1936, p. 30)
1943 - Butler family - death of unnamed infant reported (Evening Star, Aug. 24, 1933, p. 31)
1963 - David L. Good
1983 - Carl R. Sharek

Recollections

Source Material 

1910 Census (ED 36.image 7, line 19)
Boyds City Directory, 1914
Foggy Bottom News, June 1963, member directory
EHT Traceries, historic house survey, 11/1983
FBA History Project, "Working-Class Row Houses." Clio: Your Guide to History. https://theclio.com/tour/2098/3
FBA History Project, "The Historic District's Longest Row." Clio: Your Guide to History. https://theclio.com/tour/2098/18
Sumner School Archives, D.C., Briggs Elementary School, student records, 1920/21.

Street view (D. Vogt, May 2022)

2431 I St rear upper balcony and lower doors to brick patio area, realtor photo, 2020

2431 I St, artist's rendering of the facade, 2019

Rear facades including (white house on the left is 2431 I St.) showing L-shaped floor plan, 2024, Bright MLS photo

House layout (Redfin 2024)

  • facebook
  • Instagram - Black Circle
bottom of page